Superstore
AUCTIONS
Getty Images
Jimmie Johnson's crew work to find the source of his sudden lack of power at Pocono.

The free pass: When it's better to receive, and so on

By NASCAR.COM
August 4, 2009
04:47 PM EDT
Save Article Email Article Print Article RSS
type size: + -

With a problem under the hood of the No. 48 Chevrolet, Jimmie Johnson was headed to one of his worst finishes of the season. He made numerous stops on pit road as his crew worked, and finally succeeded, at solving the issue.

And when 500 miles from Pocono was complete there was Johnson in 13th place. Had the race gone long for a green-white-checkered ending he probably would've pulled out a top-10, that's how strong his car was at the finish.

They say sometimes it's better to be lucky than good. Johnson usually is always good. But on Monday, Johnson was lucky. Very lucky. It was the only way a car three laps down and for all intents and purposes out just a few laps before suddenly was charging toward the top 10.

The free-pass rule offers hope to drivers who have had some sort of misfortune during the course of a race to get back on the lead lap. But how many becomes too much? Jason Schoellen and Bill Kimm debate. Read both sides of the argument and weigh in with your takeexternal link. And don't forget to vote on who made the more compelling case.

Should NASCAR limit the number of free passes a driver earns in a race?

YES NO

Ibelieve in second chances, but third, fourth and fifth chances are pushing it. NASCAR's free pass to a lap-down driver helps keep the dog (in this case, the Lucky Dog) in the hunt ... but there's a fine line between keeping things competitive (one free pass) and handing out charity (four free passes).

Should the 48 team hold their heads high after rallying to finish 13th despite falling as far back as 36th, three laps down? Most definitely -- in the current system, that's quite a rally and the crew worked feverishly to get the car back up to speed. Did Johnson have a top-10 car before he was down on power? Absolutely.

But to say he deserved that finish any more than any of the 17 drivers posting lead-lap finishes behind Johnson is ludicrous. With the exception of Paul Menard, they never fell a lap down. Johnson passed a lot of cars late, but had he not been given a free lap four times over, those passes wouldn't have been for position.

I admit there is a bit of added excitement when a driver, despite some issues, can still be in the mix, but I also believe you should earn what you're given. After all, this is racing and not a bread line, right? No other sport assists a player or team who is struggling, so why should NASCAR?

Jason Schoellen, NASCAR.COM

The opinions expressed are solely those of the writer.

First of all, it's rare for a driver to receive multiple free passes in a race. The only time it really happens is on the big tracks: Daytona, Talladega, Pocono. Cars rarely are lapped at those "monsters," allowing for one driver to be multiple laps down and the only driver a lap down at the same time, a la Jimmie Johnson on Monday at Pocono.

But the truth is this isn't a problem at 95 percent of the races.

Secondly, if a driver has earned the right to get the free pass, why should he be limited? Let's say Dale Earnhardt Jr. has a flat tire and goes a lap down. He works his tail off to be the first car a lap down and gets the free pass. Forty laps later he makes a green-flag stop but goes a lap down when the caution comes out. Again, he works his way to the free pass position but because he's already earned one, he gets skipped this time and is relegated to finish off the lead lap? Where's the fairness in that?

We are talking about a rule change because of an exception, not the norm. Some drivers are going to benefit from a freebie on more than one occasion. There already are plenty of rules throughout a race; let's leave the free pass alone despite its wackiness once or twice a season.

Bill Kimm, NASCAR.COM

The opinions expressed are solely those of the writer.

The End

Share Article Save Article Email Article Print Article RSS
  • MySpace
  • Facebook
  • Digg
 
POPULAR ALERTS
or Create Your Own

Poll

Whose argument do you agree with the most?
Jason Schoellen
Bill Kimm
view results

Remember To Check Out

All External sites will open in a new browser window. NASCAR.COM does not endorse external sites.
© 2001-2009 NASCAR | Turner Sports Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Turner Entertainment Digital Network NASCAR.COM is part of the Turner Sports and Entertainment Digital Network.